ЛЕФ #4 1924 год

Π03Τ0Μ MOMHO 6b1Tb ĞesMOJiBHbiM, noTowy ΗΤΟ He ß ce ΜΟΛΒΗΤΟΒ. ΟΛΟΒ3 η 0 3 τ 3 ΗΘΡΒΑΚΟ OCTAWTCA AARA^OHHUMM, noTomy ΗΤΟ MMEH)U1,11E ymii. STOÖU cvibi- u i aTb "—He Mb imaT M NOTOMY, HTO ΗΘ Bc e rAa 00ΒΛ3Α3ΘΤ (7) c HSUKOM η03τ . HenoHHTHO, 4aAee, paccya iAeHHe y \ apHHa 0 6 KAEAR Β AHTepa r ype. Κτο aie c nopHT προ τΗΒ ΤΟΓΟ, Μτο Β AHTe p a r ype ecTb ηλ6 Η . H O 04 Η 0 Α 6 ΛΟ —H4en, Apy- r o e ΑβΛο— cMbicA. Aa pHH axHX TepMHHOB He pa sAH^aeT. BnpoweM, c r a TM Aa pHHa ecTb TOAfaKO npe^HCAOBHe κ e r o p a ô o xe o pa3H0BH4H0CTHX xy40aţecTBeHH0H p e i H. Aa pHHy QCTaeTCH e i ye n0Ka3aTb, κ 3κ OH H3yqaeT xyAoasecTBeHHyio p e « b , , o r r p a - HH^HBaacb OT AHHrBHCTHKH . ΗΤΟ XOTeA aBTOp CKaaaXb 3THM OrpaHHqeHHeM: HTO nOSTHKa—HC ΑΜ3Α6ΚΤΟΛΟΓΗΗ? X o p o m o , eCAH TOAbKÓ 9T0. H e Mory xaKaie ne OTMexHTb Kpaßne AypHoro H, BMecxe c TeM, yÖHHCTBeHHO πρeτeH^H03H0r0 CTHAH, KaKHM HanHcaKa cxaTbH AapHHa. FIpaBo aie, ^πHΓpaφbI H3 Pnr-BeAbi, paccyjKAeHHH o ero, AapHHa, HayqHoß r eneaAo rHH, 3ar0A0BKH, BpoAe: «Cui prosit", Bce 9το AeficTByer TaK, MTO npoqaTas cTaxbio, aaöbiBaetub Ťe npaBHAbHbie Η 3A0p0Bb1e MblCAH, KOTOpwe Β Hen HeCOMHeHHO npHCyXCTByiOT (naparpa({)b1: ApoÔAeHHe H aHaAH3, ο reHeTaqecKOM HHTepece Η Ap·)· OcTaeTCH CKa3aTb o c raxbe ^ÎKyÔHHCKoro. CxaxbH ara o n e nb HHxepecna· Β Heft cxaBHXCH Bonpocbi, a cKa3aA 6b1, nepBOcxeneHHoro 3HaqeHHH. PacCMOTpeTb flua/ioruHecKyio p e sb c TOHHM s p e n na couMaflbHO β ω τ ο ε ωχ ποΛΟίκεΗΜΗ, Β KOTopux o n a pa sBHs a eTc a, ΒΗΘΟΤΜ u,e /1eB0ií, τβΛβοΛΟΓίΐΜβοκΜΗ κορρβκτΜΒ Β oôbiHHoe ΗθΑί ιφφβ- peHiłMpoBaHHoe ΠΟΗΜΜ3ΗΙ1Θ paaroBopHOM p e n n — a a ^ a i a Hpe3Bb1MaiÍH0 ó / i a r o f l a p n aa y H3cym,H0 He06x0AMM3a. r i ocxasHB e e p n o 9τοχ s o n p o c , aBxop, OAHaKO, HBHO HC cnpaBHACH CO CBoefi 3aAa jeH· ripejKAc Bcero, aBxop, noBHAHMOiny, He y^eA, ^το ero 3a4aqa — ne npocxo AHHrBHCTHqecKaH, a cxHAMcxHqecKaH. O H HHr4e ne ynoMHHaex, MTO H3yqeHHe paSropHoro fI3bIKa c XOHKH Spenna COHHAbHWX H ÖWXOBblX yCAOBHH 40AÎKH0 CTpOHXbCH Β 3aBHCHM0CTH OT φΟρΜΜ npeAOMAeHHH Β AaHHOM HH4HBH4yaAbHbIM BbicKasbiBaHHH oöiijeH cxpyKxypw HswKa, 0611je3Ha <1HMb1x ero HopM. H o 9x0 euje HE BCH 6e4a, H 60 ecAH y aBxopa ne noA^JepKHyxa 4aHHaH cTopona 4eAa Β acneKTe MeTOAOAortmecKOM, το Ha npaKTHKc HccACAOBaHHe ΜΟΓΑΟ 6Ω OKasarbcn nocTpoen- HbiM Β HaAAejKaigHX cxHAHcxHqecKHX paMKax, Π ΛΟΧΟ, OAHaKO, HTO Ha npaKTHKe y aBTopa Hex He TOAbKO CTHAHCTHKH, HO H 9AeMeHxapH0H AHHFBHCTHKH, a no npewMyujecxBy xoAbKo ΠΟΗΧΟΑΟΧΗΗ, Η πρκ ΧΟΜ Β eecbMa ynpoixjeHHOíí φορΜε. Αβχορ xoqex Hsyqaxb φορΜΜ AHaAornqecKOH pewH, HsaAyacb, qxo panee, ecAH H CraBHAHCb BOnpOCbl 9ΧΟΓΟ HopSAKa, TO TOAbKO Β OTHOUieHHH ^ΟΛΟΒΜΗ p a s r o - BOPHOH p e q n , Β OTHOUieHHH ce. ?KaAoöa cnpaBeAAHBaa, HO y ÎÎKyÖHHCKoro Ha BceM Π0ΗΧΗ npoxHHteHHH cxaTbH p e q b HAex xojKe T0Λfaκ0 06 yc/IOBHax, a He φ0ρΜ3Χ peHH· ÄBTop Η caM c03HaeT 3 τ 0 · O H MHoroKpaTHO roBopHX ο CBoe- 6pa3HH cHHxaKCH^ecKoro cxpoH, xapaKrepH3yK)!1jeM τ ο HAH HHOC BWCKasbiBaHHe Β saEHCHMOcTH ox ycAOBHİî, HO cBoeoöpasHe 9x0 He Hsyqaex, a AHUJb npe ^ / i a r aei MSysaTb· A Β 3aKAK )qHTeAbH0M π 3 ρ 3 Γ ρ 3 φβ OH Η HpocTO yKasbiBaex: a Ke ΧΟΤβΛ 6b1, «íT06b1 9Ta cxaTba o^eHHBaΛacb Aaase, KaK nonwTKa κ HccAeAOBaHHSo 4HaA0ra''. E CAH TaK, TO 4eA0 HHoe: MW 6ΜΑΗ, OTCBHAHO, BBe4eHb1 Β 3a6Aya :4eHHe n p e 4 luecTByioigHMH oöeujaHHaMH. Mbi, 04HaK0, 40AJKHb1 6b1Tb KpaHHe npH3HareAbHb1 ílKyÓHHCKOMy yíKe 3a ca- Myw nocTanoBKy s o n p o c a , a τ3κ}κε 3a ρπΑ geHHeHiuHX saMeqaHHÍ i, BCTpeiaK)- j^HxcH Β e r o cxaTbe: TaKOBbi, Ha np . , 3aMewaHHa o cpaBHHTeAbHbix cxeneHHx aBXOMaTHIHOCTH HHCbMeHHOH Η ycTHOH pe^H, Η 4 p · Cr aTbH HanHCaHa aíHBMM, XOpOUlHM H3bIKOM. Γ. BMHOKyp.