ЛЕФ #3 1923 год

169

notjCMy Β MacrepcTBe pemi— CJOBCCHOCTH —nex πο3Η3Β3τεΛΒ!10Γ0 MOMcma? r i o q e M y , n a KO i i e u , c J O s e c H o c i b , κ β κ M a c i c p c T BO p e q n , n e BOŇAEX Β H a m a n a - .1 n3? PasyMeeicH 3Äec!> ne τ0Λbκ0 PcTopuKa i im opaxopHii", KaK noHHMaer CJIOSECHOCTB aBTop, HO H KOMROSHUMH CTHJIHCTHMECKHX 06pa30B ( Β Μ ΛΟΛΟΓΗΗ ) Η AECKPNNTHBBI Β X Y Ä O » . ΠΟ-ΚΗ; 5 ICHO, ΗΤΟ e e MM OÖO A TH n e MOMCM. /],AFLEE, iieM OT ^HHaeTCH οτ CJIOBCCHOCTH ^Hiepaxypa? Mxo XAKOE no ΜΗ 6 ΗΗΚ ) aexopa .iHTepaxypa? O H ne Äaex ΗΗΚ 3 ΚΟΓΟ NAACNEHHA Η KpaxepHa OUCHKH . Β ^Hxepa- Type, no e ro MHCHHIO , ecxb nosnaBaxejibHoe, Hero Hex Β c^osecHOcxH Η nex axHMecKoro (cHoea xyivian: ΟΛΝΗΑΊΪΗΟ npaKTiisecKii OH ΜΟ>Κ6Χ XOÄC NPUBXOÄHXB, HO jjHUJb Β HH3meH (!) cßocft cxaÄHH Η 6e3 opraHHqecKoro BHyxpeHHero ΟΛΗΗΗΗΗ. ( ! ) . HxoMe xaKoe .xnxepaxypnbie nponsBe^enui i? ,Π ΟΒΜΑΜΜΟΜΥ, C IOM MOÄHO oxnecxH, κ npHMepy, CCJIH ne uejinKOM, xo Β HaHÖoJibuiefl HacxH xBopiecxBo A. AioMa— oxua, MapKa Teena, >K. Bepna, IloHCOHa ÄIO Teppaf t j ia, BecbMa MHoroe H 3 ÄHÄaKXHiecKoft nossHH , h3 caxHpHqecKofl, 113 up0H3BeaeHHfi XVIII Βεκ3 (nanp. Β0ΛΒτερ3) BMioqaH fla>Ke Koe 1x0 H 3 3i1HrpaMMaxHqecKHX Η x. N. cxHxoxBopeHHH I lyinKHHa . .. KaK BHÄHO, aaecb jtejio HACX BOB c e He 0 HH 3 KOM KaqccTBe" 3 XHX npoHSBeaeHHň" (FI OHCOH ara Teppaä^b cxajio 6b1xb B M C O K ) ? . . . H HapoMHxo He npHBOwy Β npuMep nceił Maccbi öyjibBapHbix poManoB, rpyöoft Η 0 Ρ Η 0 Γ Ρ 3 Φ Η Η 1 ) !) Bee 3x0, Κ3Κ Η xo, qxa BCH JiHxepaxypa ecxb cn^ouiHasi TeHAeHUnn κ Π 0 3 3 ΗΗ" CJIHUIKOM n e n c H O . Hanpnivfcp, snurpaMMa FlymKHHa Ha KapaM3HHa Ero HCxopHH Hsamecxao π npocxoxa"? J lnxepaxypa ΗΛΗ n033HH? Π0 yKa3aHnoa cxeMe asxopa—^Hxepaxypa. A Meway xeM ecxb sxHqecKHň MOMenx, KOXopoMy 6b1xb HC noj i arae i ca. Cyaa no coMHHxejibHbiM aexopaM, c034aBmHM ^jiHxepaxypy", Becb TypreneB, /locxoeBCKHH, HexoB, ne roBopa ywe o flyujKHHe oxofiayx, noBHÄHMOMy, B ΠΟ 33 ΗΙΟ". Ο ΑΗ 3 ΚΟ, r ae » e y rioHcona ÄIO Teppaf lna n03HaBaxe^bHb1ft aJieMCHX Β Bbicmefł e ro cxajiHH (Β HH3u1eft ÔHsaex η Β cno- BecHOCXH, χ ο χΗ" . . . Η Χ. Λ.—IloBHÄUMOMy Bcc 3ΤΗ pa3rpaHHqeHHfl He Bbiaep- >KHBa!ox κρΗΧΗΚιι ΦΗΚΤΟΒ. Hanp. xeMo^oraqua no CinnpHOBy JiHUJb n033Ha, HO noMeMy we HE xeMOJiornqen xox >Ke I I OHCOH Λ ! 0 TcppaňJb ΗΛΗ ÄioMa. Kanofi xoTH 6b1 Η cy6T>eKT11BHb1H KpHxepufl y aexopa ΜΆ onpeae j i enna xeMOJiorniHOCTH. Kpacoxa? Xyj10>KecTBeHH0cxb? Hex: no e ro CXCMC Η Β Π 0 3 3 ΗΗ ecxb aBno npH- Haa^ewamne κ n e f t ö e c m i c . i e H H b i e cjiaöbic j n o ÖHX c j i b CKne CXHXH" (100) SnaqHx, Hex FLJIH o n p e a e ^ E H H A rpanefl 3χοΜ xpnaflbí HH 06-beKXHBHbix (ΚΛ3ΑΑΗΦΗΚ3Η;ΗΗ no cymecxseHHOMy npnanaKy) HH cy6 BCKXHBHB1X ( xyflowecxBenHO", KpacHBO", HpaBHXCH ) KPHXEPNEB. 3 3 Η 6Μ )KC xoraa 3XH xpn HayKH, xpH MOMe n x a, xpH cxaflHH? He Mowex ne öpocHXbca Β r,í1a3a CXOÄCXBO ooHcaHHoro xpHeÄHHCXBa" Π0 3 3ΗΗ c npecJioByxoii. xpnaaoft KypcoB HOSTHKH Äoöporo cxaporo BpeMeHH: McxHHa, JI06p0 Η Kpacoxa. M 6e3 c oMH e HHH, 3 x 0 ÄOJDKHO e ro K O M n p o M e x u p o B a xb Β rjiasax xex, κχο cxpeMwxca oxopsaxbca οχ Bcero ÄHBoro onbixa iipoiufloro, κ3κ οχ nepe>KHXK0B MJiaacHqecxBa. Aßxop Bcxsex Η 3 3amnxy sxoro »HBoro onbixa; Mbi HHMero npoxHB 3xoro He HMeeM. Η 3 ΧΟΑΗΜ xo^bKO, MXO 3 X 3 ocHOBaHHaa Ha onbixe" ΚΛ30όΗφΗΚ3αΗΒ, n0j10>KeHHaa Β ocHOBy e ro Mexoaoj iornn, aBHO HEYA0B^EXB0PHXEJ1BH3 11 c o s e p m e H H o HEONPABAAHHO BBOÄHX x p « MEXOAOAORHH xyAa, r ae HccjieAOBaxeJiH Η C OAHoft ΗΗΚ 3 Ι< He MOXAH c0BJ13AaTb. MexoAOAorHH 3xofl xpHaAbi ρ33ρβ60τ3Η3, no>K3^yfi, x0Λbκo BO ΒχοροΗ ee iiacxH— JiHxepa- xypHOfl", HO 3Aecb aBxop ne BHOCHX HHHero ΗΟΒΟΓΟ. MexoAbi HayKH o CAO- eecHocxH" COBCCM ne s a x p o n y x b i Η, pasyivieexca, xo HenpaeHAbHO. Mxo )κβ K3c3eTca x p e x b e H B3}KHeňmeH (nocKOJibKo HMCHHO xyaa Bce ^Hxepaxypnwe BCAH- MHHbl aBXOpOM OXBeACHbl) ÄHCUHnJIHHbl, HayKH o Π033ΗΗ , xo 3AeCb cnyxaH- HOCXb B033peHHÍÍ 3ΒΧ0ρ3 BHÄH3 OCOÔeHHO CHJlbHO. O h NPOXECXYEX npOXHB ΗΛΟ- HCHHa npoHSBCAeHHa n033HH H3 cocxaBflaromne ero MOMenxbi". M na ^Hxepa- XYPHO-NOSTHIECKHE KaxeropHH cxHJia, K01V1N03HUHH; 3 x0 H3 103 exp. a na exp. 105 OH npH3H3ex, qxo xaKoe QJIENEHHE A ^a nayqHO-HHxyHXHBHbix H xyAO- »ecTBeHHbix (!!) xapaKxepncTHK n03XHqecKHX HBJíeHHň— AonycxHMO. Ha exp. we 106 Mbi c yAHBAeHHeM y3H3eM, MX 0 3 T 3 Hay4H0-HHxyHXHBH3H x3paKxepHCXHKa óyAex « e nayKa", a KpHXHKa", HO ne xa noncxnHe HMnpeccMOHHCxcKaa AH^jiexaHxcKaa κρΗΤΗΚ3, Koxopaa yBACKaex Β nepBoe iurnoBenHe CBOHM BHemHHM öjiecKOM, a Β cjieAyromee, ηρκ ôo^ee BAyMMHBOM paccMoxpeHHH, oKasbioaexcH φ3Ηχ0Μ0Μ. j1>KHBb1M Η óecBKycHbiM ( H 60 He HayMHbiJi) a xaKaa, AJia κοχοροΚ .HayiHoe H3yMeHHe onpeACAeHHo opHeHxnpoBaJio Bce CBOH ycHAHa". flejio,